Stories · 1883

Advice

Совет

Headnote

"Advice" appeared in 1883, one of the miniature comic sketches Chekhov produced by the dozen in his Antosha Chekhonte years, when he was still a medical student paying his way by turning out copy for the humor weeklies. It is barely two pages and built like a stage direction: a door is described in mock-heroic terms, a curtain is announced at the close, and in between two unnamed men transact almost the entire plot of late-imperial Russia in overheard dialogue.

The premise is a bribe disguised as a gift. A petitioner whose case has dragged through official channels for three years wants to thank the official actually deciding it – not the clerk he is speaking to, but the unseen "Porfiry Semyonych" on the far side of the door – and the clerk, Maxim Ivanych, spends the whole scene refusing the money on his superior’s behalf while coaching the petitioner up to a sum large enough to be accepted. The refusals escalate in the same breath as the offer: two or three hundred roubles is turned away as an insult, is redescribed as gratitude rather than graft, and by the last line has become two thousand, spoken by the very man who was, a moment before, too principled to touch it.

Chekhov gives none of this a verdict. There is no narrator’s judgment on the corruption, no comment on the absurdity of "a lawful taking, so to speak" – the petitioner’s own euphemism for what he is doing. The satire lives entirely in the mechanics of the exchange: the pious vocabulary ("benefactor,purity of the soul,philanthropic... humanitarian") rising in direct proportion to the sum being negotiated, and the studied vagueness of who is asking whom for what. The mock-solemn frame – the door "breathing Olympian majesty," the curtain that falls on cue, the narrator’s coy disclaimer that what happens beyond the door is "none of our business" – turns an ordinary bribe into small theater, and lets the piece close on its own ironic aside: "let no one think ill of this."

The door is the most ordinary of doors, a room door. It is made of wood, painted with ordinary white paint, and hangs on plain hinges, but... why is it so imposing? It fairly breathes Olympian majesty! On the far side of it sits... but that, however, is none of our business.
Дверь самая обыкновенная, комнатная. Сделана она из дерева, выкрашена обыкновенной белой краской, висит на простых крючьях, но... отчего она так внушительна? Так и дышит олимпийством! По ту сторону двери сидит... впрочем, это не наше дело.
On the near side stand two men, discoursing:
По сю сторону стоят два человека и рассуждают:
"Much obliged, sir!"
– Мерси-с!
"That’s for you, sir, milk money for the little ones. For your labors, Maxim Ivanych. The matter’s dragged on three years now, no joke... Forgive me, it’s little... Only keep at it, my good sir! (A pause.) I should like, my benefactor, to thank Porfiry Semyonych... He is my chief benefactor and on him my whole affair chiefly depends... It wouldn’t hurt to present him with a gift... two or three hundred..."
– Это вам-с, детишкам на молочишко. За труды ваши, Максим Иваныч. Ведь дело три года тянется, не шутка... Извините, что мало... Старайтесь только, батюшка! (Пауза.) Хочется мне, благодетель, благодарить Порфирия Семеныча... Они мой главный благодетель и от них всего больше мое дело зависит... Поднести бы им в презент не мешало... сотенки две-три...
"Him... hundreds?! What are you saying? Have you lost your senses, my dear fellow! Cross yourself! Porfiry Semyonych is not the sort of man to..."
– Ему... сотенки?! Что вы? Да вы угорели, родной! Перекреститесь! Порфирий Семеныч не таковский, чтоб...
"He won’t take it? A pity, sir... I mean it from the heart, Maxim Ivanych... This isn’t some sort of bribe... It’s an offering from the purity of the soul... for labors beyond his strength... I’m not without feeling, I understand his labor... Who nowadays, for a mere salary, takes such a burden upon himself? Hm... Just so, sir... It’s not a bribe, sir, but a lawful taking, so to speak..."
– Не берут? Жаль-с... Я ведь от души, Максим Иваныч... Это не какая-нибудь взятка... Это приношение от чистоты души... за труды непосильные... Я ведь не бесчувственный, понимаю их труд... Кто нонче из-за одного жалованья такую тяготу на себя берет? Гм... Так-то-с... Это не взятка-с, а законное, так сказать, взятие...
"No, that’s impossible! He is such a man... such a man!"
– Нет, это невозможно! Он такой человек... такой человек!
"I know him, Maxim Ivanych! An excellent man he is! And his heart is most kind, his soul philanthropic... humanitarian... Such gentleness... He looks at you and turns your whole psychology inside out... I pray for him day and night... Only the matter drags on far too long! Well, never mind that... And for all these virtues of his I should like to thank him... Three hundred roubles, say..."
– Знаю я их, Максим Иваныч! Прекрасный они человек! И сердце у них предоброе, душа филантропная... гуманическая... Ласковость такая... Глядит на тебя и всю твою психологию воротит... Молюсь за них денно и нощно... Только дело вот слишком долго тянется! Ну, да это ничего... И за все добродетели эти хочется мне благодарить их... Рубликов триста, примерно...
"He won’t take it... His nature is different! Strictness! And don’t you go near him... He toils, he troubles himself, he doesn’t sleep nights, but as for gratitude or anything of the kind – not a whisper... Those are his rules. And besides, what does he want with your money? He’s a millionaire himself!"
– Не возьмет... Натура у него другая! Строгость! И не суйтесь к нему... Трудится, беспокоится, ночей не спит, а касательно благодарности или чего прочего – ни-ни... Правила такие. И то сказать, на что ему ваши деньги? Сам миллионщик!
"What a pity... And I did so want to show him my feelings! (Quietly.) And my affair might have moved along too... It’s dragged on three years, my good sir! Three years! (Loudly.) I don’t know what to do... I’ve fallen into despair, my benefactor... Help me out, sir! (A pause.) Three hundred I can manage... That’s certain. This very minute, even..."
– Жалость какая... А мне так хотелось обнаружить им свои чувства! (Тихо.) Да и дело бы мое подвинулось... Ведь три года тянется, батюшка! Три года! (Громко.) Не знаю, как и поступить... В уныние впал я, благодетель мой... Выручьте, батюшка! (Пауза.) Сотни три я могу... Это точно. Хоть сию минуту...
"Hm... Yes, sir... How, then, to proceed? (A pause.) Here is what I shall advise. If you truly wish to thank him for his kindnesses and his troubles, then... if you please, I’ll speak to him... I’ll report it... I can give him my advice..."
– Гм... Да-с... Как же быть? (Пауза.) Я вам вот что посоветую. Коли уж желаете благодарить его за благодеяния и беспокойства, то... извольте, я ему скажу... Доложу... Я ему посоветовать могу...
"If you would, sir! (A long pause.)"
– Пожалуйста, батюшка! (Продолжительная пауза.)
"Much obliged, sir... He’ll show you consideration... Only don’t offer three hundred roubles... Don’t go near him with that measly sum... To him it’s nothing, a nullity... vapor... Give him a thousand..."
– Мерси-с... Он уважит... Только вы не триста рублей... С этими паршивыми деньгами и не суйтесь... Для него это нуль, ничтожество... газ... Вы ему тысячу...
"Two thousand!" says someone on the far side of the door.
– Две тысячи! – говорит кто-то по ту сторону двери.
The curtain falls. And let no one think ill of this!
Занавес падает. Да не подумает о сем кто-либо худо!

Cite this passage

Advice

Pick a format and click Copy. The permalink jumps any reader to this exact section.

Support this project

Free to read here. Buy the ebook to support the work.

Ebook coming soon

The ebook edition in this language is on its way.(English)