Letter · 1888

To I. L. Leontyev, 31 December 1888. Moscow.

И. Л. ЛЕОНТЬЕВУ (ЩЕГЛОВУ), 31 декабря 1888 г. Москва.

Headnote

1 Written from Moscow on 31 December 1888 to Ivan Leontyevich Leontyev, who wrote under the pen name "Shcheglov" and whom Chekhov here addresses by the affectionate nickname "Jean" – a New Year’s letter, brief and warm, mixing holiday greetings with theater news touching both correspondents’ plays.

2 After the dateline (1-2), Chekhov opens with New Year’s wishes for Shcheglov’s health and literary productivity, framed half seriously, half as a joke about Shcheglov’s prolific output and his frustration with theater work (3). He reports that the actor and director Nikolai Solovtsov visited and discussed Shcheglov’s play, which Solovtsov wants to stage (4). He then turns to his own play "Ivanov": the director Fyodorov-Yurkovsky wants to give it as his benefit performance in Petersburg, with the actresses Strepetova and Savina, and Chekhov suspects Potekhin is behind the gesture as well (5). But Chekhov is anxious about the play’s flaws and has written asking that it be withdrawn if it fails to meet conditions he specified in a separate letter, reasoning that a play given such prominence deserves to be excellent (5-6). He reiterates that the flaws are incurable, in his own judgment and that of trusted others, and tells Shcheglov to forget about "Ivanov" and wait for his next play (6). The letter closes with an invitation to visit Moscow if Shcheglov’s own play is staged, a note on the cold weather, a domestic detail about sending the household’s Misha out for wine to see in the New Year, and closing good wishes and signature (7-10).

31 December 1888. Moscow.
31 декабря 1888 г. Москва.
31 Dec.
31 дек.
Happy New Year and new happiness, dear Jean! May the Creator grant you health, good nerves, and success in all your affairs. I wish that in 1889 you may write 8 novellas, 120 Saturday pieces, 1 novel, and? plays. I wish that you may come to hate the theatrical business and give yourself over wholly to what befits a staff officer of literature such as yourself.
С Новым годом и с новым счастьем, милый Жан! Дай Вам создатель здравия, хороших нервов и успеха во всех Ваших делах. Желаю, чтобы в 1889 году Вы написали 8 повестей, 120 субботников, 1 роман и? пьесы. Желаю, чтоб Вы возненавидели театральное дело и отдались бы всей душой тому, что прилично такому штаб-офицеру в литературе, как Вы.
Solovtsov called on me and sat for about an hour to an hour and a half. We talked about your play. He has received it and wants to stage it.
Был у меня Соловцов и просидел около 1–1 Ґ часа. Говорили о Вашей пьесе. Он получил и хочет поставить.
Fyodorov-Yurkovsky, the director of your theater, has expressed a wish to put on my "Ivanov," with Strepetova and Savina, for his benefit performance. This is flattering to me, of course, and I am pleased and gratified. It appears that Potekhin, too, wishes to do me a kindness and to prove to you for the thousandth time that I am not Chekhov but Potemkin. The roles have already been assigned, but... but the production will scarcely take place. The shortcomings in my play frighten me so, and these shortcomings matter so much, that in all conscience I cannot be indifferent to them. Today I sent off a letter in which I listed certain conditions; if, in the opinion of those to whom I wrote, my play fails to satisfy even one of these conditions, then I earnestly asked that my play be withdrawn. You must agree, my dear fellow, that a play which is being given preference, before the eyes of all Petersburg, over plays by Mey and Victor Hugo ("Hernani"), ought to be an excellent one; agree to that, and you will understand that I am not putting on airs or being coy. I am doing what you yourself would do in my place, and what Suvorin would do, and what any even moderately self-respecting person who does not write plays every day would do.
Режиссер вашего театра Федоров-Юрковский изъявил желание поставить в свой бенефис моего "Иванова" со Стрепетовой и с Савиной. Это, конечно, лестно для меня, и я польщен и рад. По-видимому, и Потехин желает сделать мне приятное и доказать Вам в 1001-й раз, что я не Чехов, а Потемкин. Роли уже распределены, но... но постановка едва ли состоится. Меня так пугают недостатки в моей пьесе и так важны эти недостатки, что я, по совести, не могу быть равнодушен. Сегодня я послал письмо, в котором перечислил некоторые условия; если по мнению тех, кому я писал, моя пьеса не удовлетворяет хотя одному из этих условий, то я серьезно просил взять мою пьесу обратно. Согласитесь, голубчик, что пьеса, которой на глазах всего Питера отдается преимущество перед пьесами Мея и Виктора Гюго ("Эрнани"), должна быть отличной; согласитесь, и Вы поймете, что я не ломаюсь и не кокетничаю. Я делаю то, что на моем месте сделали бы и Вы, и Суворин, и всякий мало-мальски самолюбивый человек пишущий пьесы не часто.
And the shortcomings in my play are incurable. I am not the only one who sees them, but also people whom I fully trust and whose competence I rank above my own. Wait until I write another play, and to hell with "Ivanov"!
А недостатки в моей пьесе непоправимы. Вижу их не я один, но также и люди, которым я вполне доверяю и компетенцию которых ставлю выше своей. Ждите, когда напишу другую пьесу, а на "Иванова" начихайте!
Come to Moscow, if they are going to stage your "Theater-Lovers." We are having hard frosts here.
Приезжайте в Москву, если будут ставить Ваших "Театралов". У нас морозы.
I have sent Misha out for wine – I want to see in the New Year.
Послал Мишу за вином, хочу Новый год встречать.
Be well and happy.
Будьте здоровы и счастливы.
Yours, A. Chekhov.

Cite this passage

To I. L. Leontyev, 31 December 1888. Moscow.

Pick a format and click Copy. The permalink jumps any reader to this exact section.

Support this project

Free to read here. Buy the ebook to support the work.

Ebook coming soon

The ebook edition in this language is on its way.(English)